Thursday, August 20, 2026

Ana Mendieta @ Tate Modern

Ana Mendieta, 

It's difficult to look at Ana Mendieta's art without seeing her death foretold. The current exhibition at Tate Modern does not mention her fall from the 34th floor of her apartment building in New York, widely believed to have been at the hands of her husband artist Carl Andre. I mention this because the work, made of blood, feathers, fire and earth is fiercely feminist and relentlessly searching for the expression of woman's connection to the ancient land and nature. As it is presented in this exhibition, Mendieta's art tells of a woman fighting to be heard amid the din of voices wanting to silence her. 

Ana Mendieta, Old Westbury, 1978, Recreated 2026

If ever there was an exhibition of a single artist's work to convince of the value of seeing the artist's development across a number of years, Tate Modern's presentation Mendieta's astonishing work shows this. The human form drawn, burnt, painted, traced and planted is always that of her own small body. More often than not, the shapes and images are vaginal, leaving no doubt that her primary concern centered on woman's place in the world, her body as an extension of nature, merged together in a spiritual harmony that has no place or need of men. In her sculptures, performances, films and drawings, trees, leaves, and the earth show the absence and silence of woman in a culturescape overwhelmed by men, as well as the violence committed on both her and nature. 

Ana Mendieta, La Concha de Venus, 1982

In, for example, La Concha de Venus (1982) the patterns of the earth give us the unmistakeable form of a woman and in the Silueta Series among othes, the woman's body is both the absent form and the clitoris of the earth. Absence is also found throughout Mendieta's oeuvre, so often the body being marked by a shadow, or a trace, a silhouette or just a negative space. And in these works, the silhouette or shadow is always removed from the body, the woman herself missing from the scene. Because she is absent, the violence is not explicit, but it is unmistakeable. 

Ana Mendieta, Silueta Series, 1973-1980

While the form remains constant, the materials, location, the medium are always shifting. Perhaps most exciting in this exhibition are the screening of a number of Mendieta's short films. In them we see her transforming, emerging, drawing, always in motion, always in the process of creating or exploring the synergy of woman and nature. In one she slowly drags her blood soaked arms down a white wall creating traces like ancient hieroglyphs along the wall. There are clear references to archaeology, ancestral ritual and neolithic cultures, very old traditions both relating to her native Cuba and her American life. The works often resemble tombs and gravesites where fire and water and snow are in a process of the exchange of life force with woman's body. And we see spaces and places where silence, absence and invisibility are remembered—or not—as forms and traces are washed away. Like the woman's body. Erased.

Ana Mendieta, Film Still from Blood and Feathers, #2, 1974

Walking through the exhibition, there's a grief in all of the works, particularly for those aware of Mendieta's premature death. That said, Tate Modern and the curators are to be congratulated  for not drawing attention to her "fall" from a window, not adding any more sensation to her death that it already attracts. Because what Mendieta has to say in her art about the fragility and vulnerability, the oppression of woman, the violence to the environment and women alike, needs to be where our attention is focussed. It is an extraordinary oeuvre and exhibited with care and creativity by Tate Modern.  





Giacometti in the Tanks @ Tate Modern

The exhibition of a dozen Giacometti sculptures in the former oil tanks underneath Tate Modern is an exquisite display of his work. The experience of being in these haunting dark spaces is breathtaking. I have seen Giacometti's men walking, women standing, their bodies trapped by the intensity of their material, in memorable settings. At the Art Institute of Chicago, at the Louisiana Museum in Copenhagen and here in Paris at the Montparnasse atelier being stand out displays of the emaciated, elongated bronzes. But the fragility and vulnerability of misshapen bodies so beautifully articulated by sparse lighting and hard concrete walls in the depths of Tate Modern took them to another level. 


I thought I would pop in to see these familiar works on my way out of the Mendieta exhibition, but I was so entranced by the quiet reflection, the delicacy of Giacometti's figures that I struggled to leave them. So much of the tone of the exhibition is in the chiaroscuro lighting, as if the bronze figures are shyly hiding underneath the great bulwark of a building. They are frail and vulnerable, misshapen, some even missing limbs, and their shadows distorted against the industrial walls of the oil tanks, hardened concrete with its own variations in wear and tear. Interestingly, contrary to Tate's website, I didn't think they evoked the isolation and alienation of Giacometti sculptures in other settings. Rather, they were resilient, quietly reflecting on their entrapment, enclosed by the darkness of shadow. 


The tanks were constructed for oil storage when the  building was a power station. The subterranean spaces are everything that a gallery with windows looking out to Millennium Park in Chicago are not. While Giacometti's figures are often surrounded by windows to accentuate their motion, in the underground world of the Blatnavik building, it is their stasis, their inward reflection and contemplation on their incarceration that is emphasised, making their weakness all the more apparent. This is a masterful instance of curation. 

Monday, August 10, 2026

James McNeill Whistler @ Tate Britain

 

James McNeill Whistler, Nocturne: Blue and Silver, Chelsea, 1871

As to be expected, the highlight of the Whistler exhibition at Tate Britain is the room devoted to the Nocturnes. It is a rare treat to see so many in one room, together reflecting and meditating on the River Thames, soaked in industrial life in the 1870s. They are breathtaking. I believe that the Nocturnes set Whistler apart from all other painters of his time. His courage to paint these radical, almost abstract visions of industrial London, their haunting contemplation so at odds with how others were looking at industrial modernity. Peaceful, serene, at a moment in the day when light is ephemeral, gone in a split second, there is nothing in Whistler's paintings of the modern life so often painted by others in this period. Subject matter aside, what makes the Nocturnes  radical and unique is their technique. At the time, the thin, whisper-like watery paint was considered outrageous. Whistler's paintings were unfinished, some said. But the scraped away, thinned out paint on unprimed canvases is what enabled Whistler to capture the very special light of this time of day. The Nocturnes, together in one room, literally glow in their quiet meditative vision of what painting can do but had not yet dared. 

James MacNeill Whistler, Nocturne: Blue and Silver - Cremorne Lightrs, 1872

Another delightful element of the exhibition were the drawings and pastels and watercolours that Whistler did as he travelled from city to city, many of which I had not seen before. In his later years, after he had been rejected by the art world, Whistler was interested in cities built around water - London, Amsterdam, and of course, Venice. Paris in the earlier years of his career was filled with the hustle and bustle of daily life in the backstreets, the medieval parts of the city. But the most exquisite drawings were those that captured the reflections of light on water moving, lapping, and trundling around buildings in Venice and Amsterdam.

James McNeill Whistler, Nocturne: Blue and Silver, The Lagoon, Venice, 1879-80

Whistler began scraping and rubbing and distressing the canvas very early in his career. His various techniques of pulling paint off a canvas rather than layering it on are evidenced in some of his earlier full length portraits. The scraped away areas on the canvas are in abundance, directing the viewer's attention to the face, or to the mood created in paint, away from any emphasis on story or character. Whistler's works are about air and light and "breath on the surface of a pane of glass" to quote him. They are not character studies or narrative paintings. Whistler wanted to do something that was only acheiveable through paint, using paint in a new way to create mood, the elements, and times of day. Of course, there was no question that this would bring with it the visibility of the canvas weave. No wonder critics such as John Ruskin were up in arms: Whistler was an outlier, and eventually, cast out for his innovation. 

James McNeill Whistler, Symphony in White no. 2, 1864
James McNeill Whistler, Arrangement in Black, 1882-86

I was disappointed - perhaps predictably - with the lack of mention of his repeated use of greys and greens, and the falling of figures' clothes into the background - even the white girl loses her definition to grey as her face melts in the mirror. Whistler was always striving for the musicality of colour - the ethereality of his painted canvas had to mimic the objectlessness of music. But so often this was only possible through his exploration of paint application and resonance, something best acheived through a radical use of greys, greens and their shadows.

James McNeill Whistler, Note in Pink and Brown, 1880

The exhibition also focused on the Japanese influence of Whistler's style and composition, shown through exhibition of prints by some of the Japanese masters such as Hiroshige. Whistler's radical flattening of the canvas is the most obvious result of this influence. His removal of the diagonal from the composition and created these very flat and lateral compositions in paint, chalk and pastel equally. In Amsterdam, for example, buildings dissolve into air, layers of life in their floors. Then when he begins to paint the Nocturnes the flatness, lack of perspective, and horizontality becomes the perfect strategy to represent air. While it might be smog filled, it is air, creating all but abstract spaces in which figuration is a shadow, a hint of a person. People and things were not important to Whistler, but always composition, colour., and the magic of translating the air into an image were what mattered most. 

James McNeill Whistler, Courtyard on Canal, Grey and Red, 1880

Ultimately, Whistler showed extraordinary uniqueness; still today, his work is singular in its technique and aesthetic. It is true that he was exploring similar issues to those of French painters of his time. For example, the fascination with daily life as seen in Manet's paintings, the capturing of light on the canvas of Monet. But he took it one step further thanks to the thinness of his paint and the push to full abstraction in the 1870s. It's difficult to overstate how radical that was.  Where cloth is all but indistinguishable from the background and cities are interesting for their patterns and reflections, not for the realism of the lives lived therein. What an inspiration he was, and remains today!