Saturday, January 31, 2009

Encounters at the End of the World, Werner Herzog, 2007


I braved the crowds once again at the Centre Pompidou to get into the Herzog retrospective tonight. (See my review of Fata Morgana). 

And, as always, I wasn't disappointed. Encounters at the end of the World is familiar because we have seen Herzog go many times before to far off lands to discover the eccentrics who inhabit them. And, even though the outsiders who are the subject of this recent documentary are in Antarctica, like all Herzog's visionaries who, removed from the insanity of the everyday world that clutters the mind and the spirit, they too impart wisdom and understanding of otherwise infathomable phenomena. 

Despite the repetitiveness of Herzog's documentaries, I always notice something different, something that seems so obvious, I wonder why I never noticed it before. Tonight I was fascinated by the invisible line trodden by Herzog in his ability to represent the humor in and of his subjects, while granting them the utmost respect and sincerity, and simultaneously inviting his audience to marvel at the subjects' enlightened ability to see a truth about the world that isn't available to the likes of us who obey the routinization of life in ... well, Paris, for example. So, on McMurdo Research Station we meet scientists who stage an "open air concert" on a rooftop in sub-zero temperatures at the South Pole in celebration of the day's esoteric molecular discovery on the ocean floor. Or the adventurer whose one woman show at the talent night sees her zipped up as carry on luggage. And then there is the linguist turned horticulturalist who ends up being a philosopher before Herzog's camera. He tells his story and weaves it with that of the rapid extinction of languages, likening his plight to preserve natural species as akin to his failed doctoral dissertation in linguistics. Herzog interrupts him, "making a long story short" and yet, somehow, we don't feel the intrusion as invasive or violent. And still we are convinced by the linguist's argument. How does Herzog do that?




My  favorite moment of Herzog as facilitator of the profundity of other people's stories, and the greatness of their lives, comes when he interviews a man who spent years behind the iron curtain. Asked about his escape, the man is not only speechless, he becomes visibly distressed, agitated and panicked. Herzog's gentle voice reassures him he doesn't have to tell his story if he doesn't want to, and immediately the trauma evaporates. This moment touches me at some deep level, not the man's physical expression of his trauma, but in Herzog's gentle witnessing of it which, in turn, enables the filmmaker to relieve his subject's trauma, to take on its burden. It's a very powerful and deeply moving few seconds in an otherwise light film.
 
I haven't mentioned the incredibly natural formations of the ice in Antarctica, I haven't mentioned the breathtaking scenery, the adorable and splendorous animal and plant life in this film. In many ways, encounters with them are more fascinating than are the human kind. Because these animals and natural formation are way beyond our comprehension. Way out of our league. Everything from their behavior, through their physical appearance, their habits, and the sheer magic of their ability to survive in these harsh conditions, none of it is rationalizable. Still that doesn't stop us. There's a wonderful physicist who explains the project of collecting particles that appear in a flash that lasts something like a 100,000,000,000,000,000 of a second. He refers to these particles as so ethereal, ephemeral that they are like spirits, like God. And because we are human, we have to make every attempt to control them! Even though the scientific research and experiments on McMurdo are shown as completely eco-friendly and responsible, it's this attitude that has lead to the film's ultimate message: it's all on the way to extinction, including us!

Friday, January 30, 2009

Josef Albers, Study for Homage to the Square, 1976


There are many delights in the group show "On Paper," currently on exhibition at Galerie Karsten Greve in the Marais, and this small oil on cardboard by Josef Albers is among them. (See also my review of Norbert Prangenberg's paintings). I have seen it and others like it in reproduction, both in his own book, Interaction of Color and in books that discuss the optical interactions of color and chromatic effects on which Albers is the authority. But up close, in person, Study for Homage to the Square is precious and intimate in a way that never is when captured in reproductions.  The object itself is delicate and, in close up, carefully, but not flawlessly executed. Just to experience the edges of grey where they bleed into the green of the background, and the moments where the green seeps over onto the white of the cardboard makes standing before the square a delight. Because these moments tell of the presence and influence of the hand in works that are always touted as evenly painted, focussed on the form of the square, the choice of the colors, and the optical interaction between them. It is only when we have the privilege of seeing the square in person that we begin to appreciate paint, color, light are inseparable, all permeating the substance of the others, all lending their luminosity to provide definition and identity to the others. This may not be what Albers intends to teach in his lessons on color, but it is what I learnt as I examined this delicious green and grey square this afternoon.

My friend Georgia was fascinated by the placement of the square on the white paper background. The right edge of the green square doubles as the edge of the paper, while the left, top and bottom edges are constituted by the three-sided white frame of the same paper. Why did he do that? The placement of the square on the paper does not introduce imbalance to the composition, but in a work that is focussed on the relationship between the adjacent colors and the effect of these on the human eye, it cannot be a random choice on the part of Albers. To be sure, in spite of conventional wisdom on Albers, there is nothing neutral, homogeneous or symmetrical in this or any other of his squares. They are replete with intimacy, asymmetricality, unevenness, varying intensity of colors, and other traces of the interaction between the hand and eye that paints them.

Sunday, January 25, 2009

The ridiculous delusion of having to settle down and resign from Life


Revolutionary Road, dir. Sam Mendes, 2008

I saw Kate Winslet in The Reader a few weeks ago and was stunned by her performance as Hannah, a woman with a past in Auschwitz who falls in love with a 15 year old boy 20 odd years after the end of WWII. However, having seen Revolutionary Road tonight, I realize that The Reader is a film that isn't strong enough or deep enough to make her shine to her full brilliance. Revolutionary Road, on the other hand, has what it takes. She is extraordinary. The film is stronger, much stronger than American Beauty. In fact, I can't remember the last time I saw one of these American middle-class angst films and was so engaged by it. Much of my engagement has to do with Winslet's performance - why she didn't get an academy award nomination for this role is beyond me. As her marriage unravels, so does she. The undoing of her marriage is spawned by the inability of her husband to face the truth about himself (to feel real emotion), and her inability to resolve herself to a life in Connecticut taking out the garbage, making scrambled eggs, going on double dates with Milly and Shep, and of course, breeding. Her understandable inner turmoil, frustration, entrapment and finally resignation to all of these, become written on her face in the subtlest of gestures, which sometimes means no gesture at all. Powerful. As a woman brought up in a world that gave me, to use her words, the idea that I had "to buy into the same ridiculous delusion, this idea of having to settle down and resign from life" in order to be accepted, I identified with every one of her protestations. Including her ultimate decision to halt the perpetuation of the illusion by using the only means left available to her: her body. It's a powerful statement about the choices, and lack thereof, of suburban women to break out of the template for life that the world gives us.

And men? I have never been a fan of Leonardo DiCaprio, even though I will admit he has matured as an actor. Still, I had difficulty feeling any empathy for Frank Wheeler, though empathy is what he really needs. Trapped by his own image of what a man must and can do, of what makes life safe, the energy we believe he has (because his wife tells us so) has nowhere to go but to well up inside of him. And then, of course, it is expended in sex with the secretary and violent outbursts against his wife. It's a familiar story. My sense is that, though the film is set in 1950s America, and specifically relates a middle-class dream, its message is really more general in nature. Sadly, the disintegration of this "perfect" couple, an erosion of private life thanks to a struggle to fit the mold of the bourgeoise nuclear family life, is way too common an occurrence in our suburbs, today. 

Mendes handles all of this social indictment with skill, and I have few criticisms of the way the film is put together. The use of a clinically insane sage to put the film's message into words was perhaps overwrought. Similarly, I found the film's opening with a violent argument between DiCaprio and Winslet as the exposition of their relationship to be too much too soon. For some reason I would have liked to have seen DiCaprio's rage build up across the film, rather than have it introduced, then disappear - ie. when he was all ready to leave the Connecticut suburbs and his detested job in sales. When the rage all of a sudden evaporates, and he becomes the loving husband who seems to have no emotional baggage, his character becomes uneven and loses credibility.

Despite its flaws, go see it, and hopefully, it will put you off marriage and life in the suburbs - FOREVER!